Head-to-Head Comparison
SIP vs FD: Systematic Investment Plan vs Fixed Deposit
Compare the wealth-generation potential of Equity Mutual Fund SIPs against the capital safety of Bank Fixed Deposits.
Option A
Equity Mutual Fund SIP
Disciplined monthly investing for compounding long-term wealth
Expected Yield / Cost:11% - 14% p.a. (Historical Equity CAGR)
Tax Treatment:12.5% LTCG above ₹1.25L exemption (held > 1 yr)
Best Suited For:
Goals 5+ years away (Retirement, Children's Higher Education, Wealth Creation)
Key Advantages
- 12% to 14% historical annualized returns
- Beats inflation consistently over 7+ years
- Tax efficient (12.5% LTCG with ₹1.25L annual exemption)
- High liquidity without lock-in (except ELSS)
Drawbacks & Risks
- Subject to short-term market volatility
- Returns are not guaranteed
Option B
Bank Fixed Deposit (FD)
Guaranteed fixed interest returns with zero market risk
Expected Yield / Cost:6.5% - 7.5% p.a. (Fixed)
Tax Treatment:Fully taxable at slab rate under Other Sources
Best Suited For:
Short-term goals (under 3 years), Emergency Funds, and Senior Citizens seeking steady income
Key Advantages
- 100% guaranteed principal and interest rate
- Insured up to ₹5 Lakh by DICGC per bank
- Predictable cash flow and tenor
- Zero market volatility
Drawbacks & Risks
- Low post-tax returns (4.5% - 5.5% in 30% slab)
- Barely beats or lags real inflation
- Penalty on premature liquidation
The Ankiva One Verdict & Action Plan
For horizons longer than 5 years, diversified equity SIPs have historically offered higher growth potential against inflation, while FDs provide capital protection for emergency reserves and immediate goals. A balanced approach aligned with your goal timeline is generally prudent.